I always make a stop by this place whenever I'm in the area. Such a charming oddity with its rom com heritage on every inch of the walls. Some nods to Mystic native screenwriter Jason Filardi as well!
I recommend the house special. I personally love this pizza. Whoever says otherwise has no taste buds! Lovely town, lovely place to eat. During the Tourist season it does get busy though!
"A Slice of Heaven" ~ Some "famous" places don't live up to the hype... Stick to the classic plain cheese or pepperoni and you won't go wrong here! Just as good or better then the hype! 🍕
The pizza here reminds me of what Pizza Hut’s pizza used to be like from the 90s. This is not a bad thing, it is still quite delicious and the taste certainly brings back some nostalgia!
Wasn't new haven pizza but not bad @ all! Seafood delight had large shrimp/scallops & was really good! Meatza was packed with meat, loved that u could split the pizza in half with the specialities!
I returned to Mystic Pizza salivating at the notion of devouring a slice of one of its renown delectable Italian pies. But to my astonishment I bit into a poorly under-cooked pizza that ruined my day
Ordered a House special, but I think there was too much green pepper in it. On one side, the movie plays on a loop, and it was nice to see Julia Roberts in her early days.
Pizza itself is not that good (crust was a weird texture and the cheese did not taste high quality or fresh), but I think it’s worth going to for the decor and vibes.
Best pizza in town! A slice of heaven plus, "happy", bubbly, smiling crews all the time. What more can you ask for?! Get the meatza! They also serve in wheat crust.
The pizza and food there isn’t that good. I mean it’s not terrible but there are so many more better restaurants. Basically it’s some regulars that know each other and everyone else is a tourist.
Visitors still flock to this symbol of the 1988 romanticcomedy, "Mystic Pizza," starring Julia Roberts and debuting Matt Damon (his only line, "Mom, do you want my green stuff?"
I left a harsh review of this place and while I would still stop short of recommending it the food was good, better than mediocre, and the waitress was friendly albeit slow
Any place that sells slices of pizza that has been kept warm under lights shouldn't be judged for the quality of their pie. That being said, avoid the premade, unknown-age slices.