San Francisco & Bay Area
Bad Animal is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

1. Bad Animal

7.0
Santa Cruz, CA
Toko Buku · Downtown Santa Cruz · 3 tips dan ulasan
Cotogna is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

2. Cotogna

9.2
490 Pacific Ave (at Montgomery St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Italia · Jackson Square · 234 tips dan ulasan
Burger Bar is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

3. Burger Bar

6.3
251 Geary St (in Macy's), San Francisco, CA
Kedai Burger · Downtown San Francisco-Union Square · 189 tips dan ulasan
Omnivore Books on Food is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

4. Omnivore Books on Food

8.8
3885 Cesar Chavez St (at Church St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Buku · Noe Valley · 28 tips dan ulasan
Green Apple Books is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

5. Green Apple Books

9.5
506 Clement St (at 6th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Buku · Inner Richmond · 68 tips dan ulasan
Sightglass Coffee is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

6. Sightglass Coffee

9.1
270 7th St (btwn Howard & Folsom St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · SoMa · 599 tips dan ulasan
Mazarine Coffee is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

7. Mazarine Coffee

8.6
720 Market St (btwn O'Farrell & Kearny St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Downtown San Francisco-Union Square · 242 tips dan ulasan
Delfina is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

8. Delfina

8.9
3621 18th St (Guerrero St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Italia · Mission Dolores · 124 tips dan ulasan
The Apothecarium is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

9. The Apothecarium

9.4
2029 Market St (Church), San Francisco, CA
Klinik Mariyuana · Mission Dolores · 21 tips dan ulasan
Verjus is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

10. Verjus

550 Washington St (Sansome Street), San Francisco, CA
Bar Anggur · Financial District · 13 tips dan ulasan
Hook Fish Co is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

11. Hook Fish Co

9.2
4542 Irving St (btw 47th & 46th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Hidangan Laut · Outer Sunset · 36 tips dan ulasan
Outerlands is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

12. Outerlands

8.4
4001 Judah St (at 45th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika · Outer Sunset · 257 tips dan ulasan
Trouble Coffee is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

13. Trouble Coffee

4033 Judah St (at 46th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Outer Sunset · 209 tips dan ulasan
Sightglass Coffee is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

14. Sightglass Coffee

9.3
3014 20th St (at Alabama St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Mission District · 137 tips dan ulasan
Ritual Coffee Roasters is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

15. Ritual Coffee Roasters

9.0
1300 Haight St (Central Street), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Haight Ashbury · 38 tips dan ulasan
Réveille Coffee Co. is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

16. Réveille Coffee Co.

4076 18th St (btwn Castro & Hartford St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Castro · 143 tips dan ulasan
Craftsman and Wolves is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

17. Craftsman and Wolves

8.6
746 Valencia St (btwn 18th & 19th St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Mission Dolores · 294 tips dan ulasan
Tartine Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

18. Tartine Bakery

9.0
600 Guerrero St (at 18th St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Mission Dolores · 769 tips dan ulasan
Tartine Manufactory is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

19. Tartine Manufactory

8.8
595 Alabama St (at 18th St), San Francisco, CA
Kafe · Mission District · 149 tips dan ulasan
B. Patisserie is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

20. B. Patisserie

9.3
2821 California St (btwn Divisadero St & Broderick St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Lower Pacific Heights · 221 tips dan ulasan
Swan Oyster Depot is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

21. Swan Oyster Depot

8.5
1517 Polk St (btwn Sacramento & California St.), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Hidangan Laut · Polk Gulch · 218 tips dan ulasan
Mister Jiu's is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

22. Mister Jiu's

8.4
28 Waverly Pl., San Francisco, CA
Restoran Cina · Chinatown · 71 tips dan ulasan
Chong Qing Xiao Mian is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

23. Chong Qing Xiao Mian

8.5
915 Kearny St (Columbus Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Szechuan · Chinatown · 54 tips dan ulasan
Acme Fine Wines is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

24. Acme Fine Wines

7.8
1080 Fulton Ln (Railroad Ave), Saint Helena, CA
Kedai Anggur · 4 tips dan ulasan
Lady Falcon Coffee Club is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

25. Lady Falcon Coffee Club

8.3
1396 La Playa St (at Steiner St), San Francisco, CA
Truk Makanan · Alamo Square · 3 tips dan ulasan
Noe Valley Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

26. Noe Valley Bakery

8.9
4073 24th St (btwn Castro & Noe St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Noe Valley · 56 tips dan ulasan
La Mexicana Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

27. La Mexicana Bakery

2804 24th St (York), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Mission District · 5 tips dan ulasan
Mr. Holmes Bakehouse is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

28. Mr. Holmes Bakehouse

1042 Larkin St (at Sutter St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Lower Nob Hill · 159 tips dan ulasan
Jane the Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

29. Jane the Bakery

9.3
1881 Geary Blvd (at Steiner St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Fillmore District · 26 tips dan ulasan
Thorough Bread and Pastry is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

30. Thorough Bread and Pastry

9.1
248 Church St (btwn Market & 15th St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Mission Dolores · 188 tips dan ulasan
City Lights Bookstore is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

31. City Lights Bookstore

9.0
261 Columbus Ave (at Broadway), San Francisco, CA
Toko Buku · Chinatown · 129 tips dan ulasan

32. Kantine

San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Financial District · Tak ada tips atau ulasan
20th Century Cafe is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

33. 20th Century Cafe

198 Gough St (Oak), San Francisco, CA
Kafe · Civic Center · 121 tips dan ulasan
Vive La Tarte is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

34. Vive La Tarte

8.6
4026 24th St (Noe), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Noe Valley · 13 tips dan ulasan
Heath Ceramics is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

35. Heath Ceramics

9.3
2900 18th St (btwn Florida & Alabama St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Perabotan / Rumah · Mission District · 35 tips dan ulasan
Ferry Building is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

36. Ferry Building

9.3
1 Ferry Building (at The Embarcadero), San Francisco, CA
Pasar · Financial District · 478 tips dan ulasan
Arsicault Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

37. Arsicault Bakery

9.3
397 Arguello Blvd (at Clement St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Inner Richmond · 110 tips dan ulasan
Marla Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

38. Marla Bakery

3619 Balboa St (at 37th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Outer Richmond · 39 tips dan ulasan
Lord Stanley is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

39. Lord Stanley

8.2
2065 Polk St (Broadway), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Eropa Modern · Polk Gulch · 20 tips dan ulasan
Al's Place is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

40. Al's Place

8.2
1499 Valencia St (at 26th St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Mission District · 82 tips dan ulasan
Souvla is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

41. Souvla

9.1
531 Divisadero St (btwn Hayes & Fell St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Souvlaki · Panhandle · 58 tips dan ulasan
Burma Love is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

42. Burma Love

8.9
211 Valencia St (Duboce Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Myanmar · Mission District · 146 tips dan ulasan
Gracias Madre is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

43. Gracias Madre

8.1
2211 Mission St (at 18th St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Meksiko · Mission District · 255 tips dan ulasan
Little Gem is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

44. Little Gem

400 Grove St (at Gough St), San Francisco, CA
Kafe · Hayes Valley · 54 tips dan ulasan
Little Gem is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

45. Little Gem

2184 Union St, San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika · Union Street · 1 tips
General Store is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

46. General Store

8.1
4035 Judah St (btw 45th & 46th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Serbaneka · Outer Sunset · 21 tips dan ulasan
The Shed is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

47. The Shed

7.7
3100 Golden Gate Dr (at Stanly Ln), Napa, CA
Kedai BBQ · 2 tips dan ulasan
Black Bird Bookstore is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

48. Black Bird Bookstore

9.1
4541 Irving St (47th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Buku · Outer Sunset · 6 tips dan ulasan
Bi-Rite Market is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

49. Bi-Rite Market

9.3
550 Divisadero St (btwn Hayes St & Fell St), San Francisco, CA
Pasar · Alamo Square · 77 tips dan ulasan
Bi-Rite Market is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

50. Bi-Rite Market

9.1
3639 18th St (btwn Guerrero & Oakwood St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Kelontong · Mission Dolores · 137 tips dan ulasan
Papalote Mexican Grill is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

51. Papalote Mexican Grill

8.6
3409 24th St (btwn Valencia St & San Jose Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Meksiko · Mission District · 255 tips dan ulasan
El Faro is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

52. El Faro

6.9
82 1st St (at Mission St), San Francisco, CA
Tempat Burrito · Financial District · 20 tips dan ulasan
Taqueria El Farolito is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

53. Taqueria El Farolito

9.1
2779 Mission St (at 24th St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Meksiko · Mission District · 391 tips dan ulasan
Taqueria La Cumbre is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

54. Taqueria La Cumbre

6.7
515 Valencia St (at 16th St), San Francisco, CA
Kedai Taco · Mission District · 61 tips dan ulasan
Lazy Bear is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

55. Lazy Bear

8.9
3416 19th St (at San Carlos), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Mission District · 85 tips dan ulasan
Humphry Slocombe is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

56. Humphry Slocombe

9.0
2790 Harrison St (at 24th St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Es Krim · Mission District · 376 tips dan ulasan
Salt & Straw is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

57. Salt & Straw

9.4
586 Hayes St, San Francisco, CA
Toko Es Krim · Hayes Valley · 50 tips dan ulasan
Petit Crenn is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

58. Petit Crenn

609 Hayes St (at Laguna St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Perancis · Hayes Valley · 56 tips dan ulasan
Octavia is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

59. Octavia

9.0
1701 Octavia St (at Bush St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika · Japantown · 55 tips dan ulasan
The Commissary is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

60. The Commissary

101 Montgomery (Presidio), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika · Presidio National Park · 16 tips dan ulasan
Bouli Bar is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

61. Bouli Bar

6.9
1 Ferry Building #35, San Francisco, CA
Restoran Italia · Financial District · 34 tips dan ulasan
Mission Heirloom PopUp is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

62. Mission Heirloom PopUp

865 Market Street, Space 146 (5th Street), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika · SoMa · 1 tips
Wrecking Ball Coffee Roasters is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

63. Wrecking Ball Coffee Roasters

8.6
2271 Union St (btwn Steiner St & Fillmore St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Union Street · 72 tips dan ulasan
Four Barrel Coffee is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

64. Four Barrel Coffee

9.1
375 Valencia St (btwn 14th St & 15th St), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Mission District · 510 tips dan ulasan
Saint Frank is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

65. Saint Frank

9.0
2340 Polk St (btwn Union & Green), San Francisco, CA
Warung Kopi · Polk Gulch · 201 tips dan ulasan
Trick Dog is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

66. Trick Dog

9.1
3010 20th St (at Florida St), San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Mission District · 282 tips dan ulasan
Maven is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

67. Maven

598 Haight St (at Steiner St), San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Lower Haight · 121 tips dan ulasan
Whitechapel is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

68. Whitechapel

8.5
600 Polk St (btwn Eddy and Turk St), San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Tenderloin · 113 tips dan ulasan
Cafe Du Nord is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

69. Cafe Du Nord

8.1
2174 Market St (at Sanchez St.), San Francisco, CA
Loka Musik · Mission Dolores · 49 tips dan ulasan
Che Fico is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

70. Che Fico

8.0
834-838 Divisadero St, San Francisco, CA
Restoran Italia · Alamo Square · 41 tips dan ulasan
Tacos Cala is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

71. Tacos Cala

149 Fell St ((Entrance on Hickory St)), San Francisco, CA
Kedai Taco · Civic Center · 21 tips dan ulasan
Rintaro is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

72. Rintaro

8.8
82 14th St (at Folsom St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Jepang · Mission District · 73 tips dan ulasan
State Bird Provisions is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

73. State Bird Provisions

8.8
1529 Fillmore St (btwn Geary & O'Farrell St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Fillmore District · 221 tips dan ulasan
RT Rotisserie is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

74. RT Rotisserie

8.5
101 Oak St (at Franklin St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Civic Center · 40 tips dan ulasan
Zuni Café is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

75. Zuni Café

8.6
1658 Market St (at Rose St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Civic Center · 317 tips dan ulasan
The Riddler is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

76. The Riddler

528 Laguna St, San Francisco, CA
Bar Anggur · Hayes Valley · 24 tips dan ulasan
March is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

77. March

8.1
3077 Sacramento St, San Francisco, CA
Toko Perabotan / Rumah · Pacific Heights · 8 tips dan ulasan
Proper Hotel San Francisco is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

78. Proper Hotel San Francisco

8.2
1100 Market Street, Hotel Entrance is at 45 McAllister Street (Entrance at 45 McAllister St), San Francisco, CA
Hotel · Tenderloin · 6 tips dan ulasan
Acme Bread Company is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

79. Acme Bread Company

8.7
1 Ferry Building Ste 15 (The Embarcadero), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Financial District · 50 tips dan ulasan
Devil's Teeth Baking Company is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

80. Devil's Teeth Baking Company

9.2
3876 Noriega St (btwn 45th & 46th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Outer Sunset · 163 tips dan ulasan
Good Mong Kok Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

81. Good Mong Kok Bakery

8.3
1039 Stockton St (btw Jackson St. & Washington St.), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Dim Sum · Chinatown · 94 tips dan ulasan
The Mill is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

82. The Mill

9.1
736 Divisadero St (btwn Grove St & Fulton St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Alamo Square · 375 tips dan ulasan
Plow is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

83. Plow

8.9
1299 18th St (at Texas St), San Francisco, CA
Tempat Sarapan · Potrero Hill · 385 tips dan ulasan
Molinari Delicatessen is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

84. Molinari Delicatessen

9.2
373 Columbus Ave (at Vallejo St), San Francisco, CA
Deli / Bodega · North Beach · 99 tips dan ulasan
Nopa is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

85. Nopa

9.1
560 Divisadero St (at Hayes St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Alamo Square · 557 tips dan ulasan
flour + water is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

86. flour + water

8.9
2401 Harrison St (at 20th St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Italia · Mission District · 263 tips dan ulasan
Rich Table is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

87. Rich Table

8.7
199 Gough St (at Oak St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Lower Haight · 189 tips dan ulasan
Trattoria Contadina is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

88. Trattoria Contadina

8.8
1800 Mason St (at Union St), San Francisco, CA
Trattoria/Osteria · Russian Hill · 68 tips dan ulasan
Foreign Cinema is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

89. Foreign Cinema

9.2
2534 Mission St (btwn 21st & 22nd St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · Mission District · 361 tips dan ulasan
Zeitgeist is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

90. Zeitgeist

8.7
199 Valencia St (at Duboce Ave), San Francisco, CA
Taman Bir · SoMa · 386 tips dan ulasan
Bar Bocce is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

91. Bar Bocce

8.9
1250 Bridgeway (at Humboldt St), Sausalito, CA
Tempat Pizza · 136 tips dan ulasan
Li Po Cocktail Lounge is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

92. Li Po Cocktail Lounge

7.9
916 Grant Ave (at Washington St), San Francisco, CA
Bar Selam · Chinatown · 109 tips dan ulasan
Pagan Idol is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

93. Pagan Idol

8.2
375 Bush St, San Francisco, CA
Bar Tiki · Downtown San Francisco-Union Square · 102 tips dan ulasan
El Techo is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

94. El Techo

8.9
2516 Mission St (btwn 21st St & 22nd St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Latin · Mission District · 172 tips dan ulasan
barvale is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

95. barvale

661 Divisadero St (Grove Street), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Spanyol · Panhandle · 19 tips dan ulasan
Horsefeather is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

96. Horsefeather

8.8
528 Divisadero St, San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Alamo Square · 47 tips dan ulasan
The Alembic is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

97. The Alembic

8.8
1725 Haight St (btwn Cole & Shrader St), San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Haight Ashbury · 238 tips dan ulasan
Zazie is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

98. Zazie

8.9
941 Cole St (btwn Parnassus Ave & Carl St), San Francisco, CA
Tempat Sarapan · Cole Valley · 360 tips dan ulasan
Padrecito is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

99. Padrecito

8.5
901 Cole St (at Carl St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Meksiko · Cole Valley · 123 tips dan ulasan
SPARK Social SF is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

100. SPARK Social SF

9.1
601 Mission Bay Blvd N (at 4th St), San Francisco, CA
Kumpulan Makanan Kaki Lima · Mission Bay · 32 tips dan ulasan
King of Thai Noodle is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

101. King of Thai Noodle

7.5
639 Clement St (at 8th Ave), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Thailand · Inner Richmond · 26 tips dan ulasan
Madrone Art Bar is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

102. Madrone Art Bar

8.3
500 Divisadero St (at Fell St), San Francisco, CA
Klub malam · Lower Haight · 94 tips dan ulasan
Twenty Five Lusk is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

103. Twenty Five Lusk

7.9
25 Lusk St (off Townsend St, btwn 3rd & 4th St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Amerika Baru · SoMa · 156 tips dan ulasan
Black Jet Baking Company is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

104. Black Jet Baking Company

8.4
833 Cortland Ave (Gates St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Bernal Heights · 11 tips dan ulasan
Elda is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

105. Elda

7.4
3198 16th St (Guerrero), San Francisco, CA
Bar Koktail · Mission Dolores · 5 tips dan ulasan
Le Marais Bakery is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

106. Le Marais Bakery

2066 Chestnut St (at Steiner St), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Marina District · 76 tips dan ulasan
Angler is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

107. Angler

8.3
132 The Embarcadero (Mission), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Hidangan Laut · Financial District · 17 tips dan ulasan
CAW Lab is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

108. CAW Lab

2260 Keith St (between Yosemite Ave and Wallace Ave), San Francisco, CA
Toko Roti · Bayview · 1 tips
The Marshall Store is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

109. The Marshall Store

8.9
19225 State Route 1, Marshall, CA
Restoran Hidangan Laut · 50 tips dan ulasan
Farmstead at Long Meadow Ranch is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

110. Farmstead at Long Meadow Ranch

9.3
738 Main St (at Charter Oak Ave), Saint Helena, CA
Gudang Anggur · 210 tips dan ulasan
Dear Inga is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

111. Dear Inga

3560 18th St, San Francisco, CA
Restoran Eropa Timur · Mission Dolores · 6 tips dan ulasan
Liholiho Yacht Club is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

112. Liholiho Yacht Club

9.2
871 Sutter St (btwn Jones & Leavenworth St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Hawaii · Lower Nob Hill · 162 tips dan ulasan
Bellota is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

113. Bellota

8.9
888 Brannan St, San Francisco, CA
Restoran Spanyol · Showplace Square · 70 tips dan ulasan
Kin Khao is one of San Francisco & Bay Area.

114. Kin Khao

8.3
55 Cyril Magnin St (Ellis St), San Francisco, CA
Restoran Thailand · Downtown San Francisco-Union Square · 183 tips dan ulasan